To solve this puzzle, start by thinking about the individual effects of shifts in supply and demand on the equilibrium price and quantity of bikes.
If the demand for bikes remains constant, a shift in the supply curve would result in a movement along the demand curve. If the supply of bikes remains constant, a shift in the demand curve would result in a movement along the supply curve. Either way, this causes a change in both the equilibrium price and the equilibrium quantity.
However, because the quantity of bikes remained constant in this case, both the supply curve and the demand curve must have shifted, and the effects of those shifts on the equilibrium quantity offset each other. Therefore, the curves shifted in opposite directions. Because the price of bikes decreased, the supply of bikes increased and the demand for bikes decreased.
Effects of Shifts in Demand or Supply on Equilibrium
P and Q unchanged | P ↓, Q ↑ | P ↑, Q ↓ |
P ↑, Q ↑ | P ?, Q ↑ | P ↑, Q ? |
P ↓, Q ↓ | P ↓, Q ? | P ?, Q ↓ |
(Note: The ↑ (up arrow) indicates that the equilibrium object increases; the ↓ (down arrow) indicates that it decreases; and the ? (question mark) indicates that the direction of the change is unknown.)