Quizzol

QUESTION:

For their 1992 study “The Effect of Country Music on Suicide” (published in Social Forces, vol. 71, p. 211), researchers Stack and Gundlach investigated various American communities, recording the number of minutes of daily radio airtime devoted to country songs and the suicide rate. They found a moderately strong positive correlation.

In their paper, the researchers explain the results by saying that “…the themes found in country music foster a suicidal mood ...” (emphasis added). A news headline (The Independent [London], October 1, 2004, p. 15) about the research echoed these sentiments when it said, “Strange But True: Country Music Saps Will to Live.” The research is even cited on various suicide-prevention websites, some with headings such as “Country Music Increases Suicide Risk.”

Based upon this study, can we have confidence that country music has a causal effect on suicide?

Yes, as long as the communities were sampled randomly, and the number of communities (the sample size) was sufficiently large.

Yes, causality is indicated by the moderately strong correlation.

Yes, since different communities listened to different levels of country music, meaningful experimental comparisons can be made.

No, because the lack of assignment of communities to different levels of country music listening means there is a possibility of lurking variables.

No, causality can only be demonstrated by investigating the entire population.

Good job! Causation can only be determined if the explanatory variable is randomly assigned. But in this case, the researchers didn't randomly assign different amounts of country music to be played in different communities. So the study design doesn't rule out lurking variables.

ANSWER:

No, because the lack of assignment of communities to different levels of country music listening means there is a possibility of lurking variables.

Causation can only be determined if the explanatory variable is randomly assigned. But in this case, the researchers didn't randomly assign different amounts of country music to be played in different communities. So the study design doesn't rule out lurking variables

Posted by Cleveland on September 19, 2024